We have boycotted Newman's own turkey formula for cats (Cosmo has, and I haven't extended my personal explorations of catfood to actual tasting).   As is usual, it not only contains "turkey liver" but unrelated items like "Ocean Whitefish" and intriguing additions like "organic brown rice" and "dried kelp."  It was unsightly, grayish in color, but I haven't seen Cosmo avoid ugly colored things if they're smelly and have the right texture.  After that one was over, we've gone back to the optimistically named Whiskas "Alaskan Crab."  Managed to hold him off till 5:30 today, though he did move from gentle batting to actual scratching.